Australian True Crime

Australian True Crime

Think nothing ever happens in your town? Australia's suburbs are home to some of the most mysterious and disturbing true crime cases in the world. Meshel Laurie is a true crime obsessive, and with the help of expert interviews with writers, victim/survivors, investigators and perpetrators, she probes the underbelly of our towns and suburbs, and uncovers the darkness at the heart of Australian life.

00:00
00:00

Episode's summary

In this episode of Australian True Crime, host Michelle Laurie interviews Professor Stephen Cordner, a leading expert in forensic medicine, regarding his new book, Wrongful Convictions in Australia. The discussion explores the potential for widespread miscarriages of justice within the Australian criminal justice system, using high-profile cases like Lindy Chamberlain and Kathleen Folbigg as primary examples of how scientific evidence can challenge previous convictions. Professor Cordner argues that unlike the healthcare industry, which has moved toward an evidence-based model, the Australian criminal justice system lacks a formal mechanism to proactively investigate potential wrongful convictions. He compares Australia's lack of a dedicated review commission to successful models in the United Kingdom and other nations, suggesting that without active investigation, the true scale of the problem remains unmeasured.

Chapters

Click on a chapter to go directly to that moment

Highlights

There isn't a comparable approach to preventable things in the criminal justice system.

00:01:52 · Dr. Cordner compares the evolution of evidence-based medicine to the lack of preventative mechanisms for errors in the legal system.

For people who are wrongly convicted in jail, it's got to go through, with some minor exceptions in New South Wales, it's got to go through the Attorney General, who's a politician, who's, generally speaking, fighting a law and order issue.

00:04:00 · The professor explains the political hurdles involved when seeking justice for the wrongfully convicted.

Unless we actively look, we will never know whether we've got a serious problem or not.

00:07:59 · Dr. Cordner highlights the danger of assuming the justice system is functioning correctly without active investigation.

From 1997, the average is 30. Okay, so it's not quite 10. It's seven to eight times as many because of the presence of the Criminal Cases Review Commission, as they call it in the UK.

00:08:48 · The discussion uses UK statistics to demonstrate how a dedicated commission significantly increases the identification of potential miscarriages of justice.

And they have all decided they needed such a commission and Australia is way behind and now an outsider, an outlier rather, in this space.

00:10:19 · Dr. Cordner concludes by positioning Australia as lagging behind culturally similar nations regarding justice reform.

Episodes

938-

Shortcut: How Common Are Miscarriages of Justice in Australia?

In this episode of Australian True Crime, host Michelle Laurie interviews Professor Stephen Cordner, a leading expert in forensic medicine, regarding his new book, Wrongful Convictions in Australia. The discussion explores the potential for widespread miscarriages of justice within the Australian criminal justice system, using high-profile cases like Lindy Chamberlain and Kathleen Folbigg as primary examples of how scientific evidence can challenge previous convictions. Professor Cordner argues that unlike the healthcare industry, which has moved toward an evidence-based model, the Australian criminal justice system lacks a formal mechanism to proactively investigate potential wrongful convictions. He compares Australia's lack of a dedicated review commission to successful models in the United Kingdom and other nations, suggesting that without active investigation, the true scale of the problem remains unmeasured.

12 Oct 2026
937-

How Common Are Miscarriages of Justice in Australia?

Professor Stephen Cordner discusses the lack of a formal mechanism in Australia to identify and review potential miscarriages of justice, comparing the need for reform to the healthcare system's shift toward evidence-based medicine. He highlights his involvement in the Kathleen Folbigg case and argues that without an active commission like those in the UK or US, Australia remains unaware of how many people are wrongly imprisoned. The conversation explores the potential for widespread wrongful convictions, examining specific case studies involving DNA contamination in the Farajama case and the complexities of forensic evidence in shaken baby syndrome investigations. The episode also addresses the phenomenon of false confessions and concludes with personal anecdotes from a pathologist's career regarding medical discoveries during autopsies.

11 Oct 2026
936-

True Crime Tonight: Christa Pike's Failed Execution

The hosts of True Crime Tonight discuss several high-profile criminal cases, including a botched execution in Tennessee and the murder conviction of an American Idol contestant. The episode also features an interview preview with journalist Michael Bachelard regarding the controversial science surrounding shaken baby syndrome. The discussion explores the evolution of Shaken Baby Syndrome prosecutions, which transitioned from an educational theory in 1971 to a powerful legal tool for prosecutors in the 1990s. The segment highlights growing scientific skepticism and the potential for wrongful convictions as recent evidence suggests alternative causes for the clinical triad of symptoms.

11 Oct 2026
935-

Shaken Baby Syndrome: How Certain Is the Diagnosis?

Journalist Michael Bachelard investigates the controversial science of shaken baby syndrome, focusing on how medical diagnoses can trigger an unstoppable cycle of child protection interventions and legal accusations. The episode explores a specific case where a family was separated due to inconclusive evidence and examines the systemic momentum created by police investigations and medical findings. The discussion further delves into the scientific controversy surrounding 'the triad' of injuries used for diagnosis, highlighting recent challenges to these theories and the potential for racial and socioeconomic bias in the legal system. The investigation also questions how disparities in wealth and legal representation impact the ability of parents to contest allegations and maintain their families.

07 Oct 2026
934-

Shortcut: Shaken Baby Syndrome: How Certain Is the Diagnosis?

In this episode of Australian True Crime, host Michelle Laurie interviews journalist Michael Bachelard regarding his podcast, Diagnosing Murder. The discussion explores the controversial scientific and legal implications of shaken baby syndrome, investigating how a medical theory used for education in the 1970s became a primary tool for criminal prosecution in the 1990s. Bachelard examines the tension between the instinctive desire for justice in cases of child injury and the emerging scientific challenges to the 'triad' diagnosis. The conversation delves into the potential for wrongful convictions, noting that while many view these defendants as unsympathetic, new biomechanical evidence and a greater understanding of alternative causes for brain injuries are leading to exonerations in the United States. The episode also touches upon the impact of these diagnoses on families within the Australian children's court system and the inherent biases present in investigating such high-profile, emotionally charged crimes.

07 Oct 2026